Nov 10, 1923 J. & P. Coats F.C. 3 - 3 AET Fall River F.C. Coats Field | Attendance: 10,000 Nov 18, 1923 Fall River F.C. 4 - 0 J. & P. Coats F.C. Replay Mark's Stadium | Attendance: 14,375
Nov 11, 1923 Newark S.C. 1 - 1 American F.C. Meadowbrook Oval Nov 18, 1923 Newark S.C. 1 - 1 American F.C. Replay Meadowbrook Oval Nov 25, 1923 Newark S.C. vs American F.C. Replay Meadowbrook Oval Nov 29, 1923 Newark S.C. vs American F.C. Replay Meadowbrook Oval
Nov 11, 1923 Scullin Steel Co. F.C. 2 - 1 St. Matthew's High School Field | Attendance: 3,509 Nov 18, 1923 Scullin Steel Co. F.C. 3 - 1 St. Matthew's Replay High School Field
Dec 25, 1923 Bethlehem Steel F.C. 2 - 2 AET New York S.C. Bethlehem Steel Athletic Field Dec 30, 1923 New York S.C. 3 - 4 Bethlehem Steel F.C. Replay New York Oval | Attendance: 8,000
Jan 26, 1924 Bethlehem Steel F.C. 1 - 1 AET Newark S.C. National League Park | Attendance: 2,000 Feb 2, 1924 Bethlehem Steel F.C. 6 - 0 Newark S.C. Replay National League Park | Attendance: 4,000